• Home
  • Contact
  • FAQs
    • What is Webcomics.com?
    • Member Benefits
    • How To Post an Article or News Item
    • How to Post a Webcomic on the List
    • How to Post a Comic
    • Terms of Service
  • Forums
  • WebComics List
  • Benefits
    • Print Vendors: Get multiple quotes
    • Banner stand: Discount
    • Consultation discount
    • “How To Make Webcomics” book: discount
    • “Webcomics Handbook”: discount
    • ALL benefits
  • My Account
    • Welcome
    • What is Webcomics.com?
    • My Subscription
    • Join us!
  • Account
  • Membership List
Twitter Email RSS

Webcomics.com

How To Make WebComics

WebComic Handbook

‹ Best of Webcomics.com — Dec. 2015 Ten Resolutions for a Better 2016 ›

The crossbar ‘I’

You don’t need a subscription to read today’s post!

This is a re-post from the Webcomics.com archive. If you’ve ever been curious about the kind of information, tutorials and advice that you’ll get as part of your subscription to Webcomics.com — EVERY DAY — then this is a good example.

If you’d like to join the site, you can get a 12-month subscription for $30 — or you can get a one-month Trial for $5 … with no obligation after your 30 days expire.  For less than three bucks a month, you can get a steady flow of information, tutorials and advice targeted towards your webcomic business — plus a private forum to discuss issues with other professionally minded cartoonists.

I had an epiphany today. (I know… two days too late, right?)

Teaching the lettering segment of my Sequential Arts class at Hussian College, I covered some of the basics of lettering — both hand-lettering and digital lettering.

During the course of the lecture, I described how letters have “push” and “pull” that affects their kerning. Letters that trap a lot of white space (O, Q, D, for example) push other letters away a little bit. And letters that are skinny (I, J, T and L, for example) tend to pull their neighbors in a little.

I pushed further by saying that the main mistake novice letterers make with letters such as T, J and L is that they make the horizontal aspects of those letters too wide.

lettering_tutorial2

See, when you make the horizontal line on a capital T too wide, it’s impossible to get the other letters close enough to kern it correctly.

Bad_kerned_T

And, after that I discussed the “crossbar-I rule.”

In comics, the crossbar-I rule asserts that the crossbar I (that, is, the capital letter I, drawn with serifs) should only be used for the personal pronoun* “I.” In all other instances, the sans serif capital “I” should be used.

lettering_tutorial_I_crossbar2

Now, this is a rule of thumb that has gotten a little debate on this site over the years. And, I’ll be honest with you. I’ve never been able to put into words an adequate response to people who challenge this rule. I mean, I know that I prefer the way it looks. Subjectively, I can tell you that  much. And secondly, when people like Chris Eliopoulos and Nate Piekos suggest the crossbar-I rule, I respect their proficiency so much that I tend not to question it.

But that’s not an answer to: “Why?”

I mean, you could argue that the personal pronoun “I” is the only time that a capital I could be mistaken for a number 1 or a lowercase L (l). And, therefore, it’s the only time you need the serifs as a distinction.

And that’s a darned good argument. But it’s not an answer to “why.”

So… back to Hussian College.

As I’m describing the crossbar-I rule, one of my students says, “So… you’re saying to only use the crossbar I when it stands alone?”

And, well… like I said… epiphany. The “why” suddenly struck me.

Go back to the discussion of the letters T, J and L — and how drawing the horizontal parts of those letters make it too difficult to kern them correctly.

lettering_tutorial2

That’s the “why” — from a typographer’s standpoint… because drawing the serifs on the letter I makes it too difficult to correctly kern a word containing “I.” The letter “I” gets kerned very closely. It’s one of those letters that pulls its neighbors in — only it’s harder to get as close as you need to get with those pesky crossbars getting in the way!

And words like “I’m” and “I’ll” — that technically take a crossbar-I? Well, that apostrophe creates a flexible area inside which you can adjust the kerning properly. In other words, the apostrophe doesn’t take up a lot of room, but it’s more than enough to compensate.

The crossbar I stands alone. Because it must.

Mind blown? Well, maybe not. But it has a beauty that I’d never fully realized before. Perhaps you’ll feel the same way.


*A personal pronoun takes the place of a noun. In this case, a personal pronoun “I” would be used as such: “I go to the lake.” Also: “Jim and I are pals.”

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
by Brad Guigar on January 8, 2016
Posted In: Art, Lettering
Comments available to logged in users only.


Recent comments

  • Shadowmark Productions on Eisner Awards: Call for Entries
  • Shadowmark Productions on Comicraft’s annual New Year’s Day Sale
  • Shadowmark Productions on CASE Act passes
  • Phil Maish on Comicraft’s annual New Year’s Day Sale
  • Phil Maish on Comicraft’s annual New Year’s Day Sale

Search




Webcomics.com Poll

I design my comic specifically for smartphones and digital tablets.

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
  • Polls Archive

Categories

  • Archive Dive
  • Articles
    • Advertising
    • Art
    • Business
    • Community
    • Conventions
    • Creativity
    • Crowdfunding
    • Digital publishing
    • Image prep
    • Lettering
    • Marketing / Social Media
    • Merchandise
    • Print publishing
    • Tech
    • Web site
      • Web Site Design
    • Writing
  • ComicLab
  • Edited and Ready
  • Events
  • Guest
  • Hot Seat critiques
  • Information
  • Interviews
  • Livestream Chat
  • Mail Bag
  • Member Benefits
  • Promos
  • Site News
  • Studios
  • Surviving Creativity
  • To-Do List
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • Webcomics Confidential
  • Webcomics Weekly
  • Webcomics.com Poll

Tags

AdSense advertising Comic Easel comments composition contract copyright creativity exercise credit cards Crowdfunding digital lettering digital publishing Facebook Google Analytics holiday Humor IP KDP Kickstarter Kindle legal lettering line weight Longform comics Manga Studio merchandise NCS panels Patreon Promotion PulsePoint readers revenue SEO shipping social media Square taxes trademark Twitter typography Web design word balloons WordPress writing

Special Features

Just now, in the forum…

  • Quantity time vs quality time on social media
  • Writing a Slice of life
  • Can’t Set Up WordPress Site
  • Multiple Websites for Multiple comics?
  • How many to start with?

Recent Posts

  • Eisner Awards: Call for Entries
  • Finding the right format
  • NCS Divisional Awards: Call for entries
  • The Great Twitter Bot Purge
  • Doing it for the right reasons

Recent Replies

  • Shadowmark Productions on Can’t Set Up WordPress Site
  • Brad Guigar on Can’t Set Up WordPress Site
  • Shadowmark Productions on Can’t Set Up WordPress Site
  • edustin78 on Can’t Set Up WordPress Site
  • Brad Guigar on Quantity time vs quality time on social media

Recent Topics

  • Quantity time vs quality time on social media by MrMcCloud
  • Writing a Slice of life by MrMcCloud
  • Can’t Set Up WordPress Site by edustin78
  • Multiple Websites for Multiple comics? by MrMcCloud
  • How many to start with? by Boofredlay

Recent Comments

  • Shadowmark Productions on Eisner Awards: Call for Entries
  • Shadowmark Productions on Comicraft’s annual New Year’s Day Sale
  • Shadowmark Productions on CASE Act passes
  • Phil Maish on Comicraft’s annual New Year’s Day Sale
  • Phil Maish on Comicraft’s annual New Year’s Day Sale
  • My Subscription
  • Contact
  • Store
  • Terms of Service
  • Account
  • Membership List

©2007-2021 Webcomics.com | Powered by WordPress with ComicPress | Subscribe: RSS | Back to Top ↑