• Home
  • Contact
  • FAQs
    • What is Webcomics.com?
    • Member Benefits
    • How To Post an Article or News Item
    • How to Post a Webcomic on the List
    • How to Post a Comic
    • Terms of Service
  • Forums
  • WebComics List
  • Benefits
    • Print Vendors: Get multiple quotes
    • Banner stand: Discount
    • Consultation discount
    • “How To Make Webcomics” book: discount
    • “Webcomics Handbook”: discount
    • ALL benefits
  • My Account
    • Welcome
    • What is Webcomics.com?
    • My Subscription
    • Join us!
  • Account
  • Membership List
Twitter Email RSS

Webcomics.com

How To Make WebComics

WebComic Handbook

‹ ComicLab Ep 137 — How do you do an empathy? Ellipses ›

Why do we hate thought balloons?

Comics educator and author Scott McCloud calls them the “bulgy Edsels of comics iconography.” Indeed, cloud-like thought balloons are spurned by most comics artists.

Let’s talk about why that is… and whether it’s warranted or not.

Too many thought balloons

In the early days of comic-book history, as artists and writers struggled to build the lexicon of a fledgling art form, it’s no question that the thought balloon was becoming a crutch. Instead of a glimpse into the thoughts of a character, it was a way of explaining action and plot that should have been illustrated instead.

There’s no doubt that the early Lee/Ditko Spider-Man comics were thought-balloon heavy.

In Panel One, the thought ballon “an electrically-activated mechanical bat” attempts to explain a plot feature that should have been conveyed through illustration instead. Panel Two also uses a thought balloon to do the job of the illustration. In fact, you can see it happening throughout the scene above.

As comics art matured, this overuse of expositional and explanatory thought balloons became frowned upon.

And although comics legend Jack Kirby famously used movies as inspiration for his visuals, the comics industry itself was soon regarding Hollywood as a competitor for consumer dollars as well. And comics artists were encouraged to go beyond inspiration, towards emulation.

Comics writer John Ostrander reported that he was forbidden from using thought balloons “because they didn’t have them in movies.”

Although it was a good idea to limit the overuse of thought balloons, the fact remained that conveying inner thoughts efficiently was a necessary part of some storytelling.

When writer/artist Frank Miller presented Elektra’s internal monologue in narration boxes, it quickly became adopted as a replacement for those exposition-heavy thought balloons.

Even today, narration boxes are greatly preferred for internal monologue, and thought balloons are given a weary side-eye. In fact, McCloud considers thought balloons to be patronizing in their very nature! (Somehow the pictogram thought balloons of Asterios Polyp are spared this scorn.)

In defense of the lowly thought balloon

I like thought balloons — used correctly. Those early craftspeople were right in rejecting the thought balloon used as a storytelling crutch. But criminalizing thought balloons entirely is like throwing the baby out with the bath water.

Comics writer Kurt Buseik may have put it best: “Eschewing thought balloons as a creative choice can result in interesting approaches. Eschewing them as a blanket formula, though, is just dumb.”

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
by Brad Guigar on August 7, 2020
Posted In: Lettering
Comments available to logged in users only.


Recent comments

  • Shadowmark Productions on Twitter announced paid-content feature “Super Follows”
  • Shadowmark Productions on How to launch a new comic
  • Jaycee Knight on Twitter announced paid-content feature “Super Follows”
  • Jaycee Knight on Line breaks in word balloons
  • Jaycee Knight on Line breaks in word balloons

Search




Webcomics.com Poll

I design my comic specifically for smartphones and digital tablets.

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
  • Polls Archive

Categories

  • Archive Dive
  • Articles
    • Advertising
    • Art
    • Business
    • Community
    • Conventions
    • Creativity
    • Crowdfunding
    • Digital publishing
    • Image prep
    • Lettering
    • Marketing / Social Media
    • Merchandise
    • Print publishing
    • Tech
    • Web site
      • Web Site Design
    • Writing
  • ComicLab
  • Edited and Ready
  • Events
  • Guest
  • Hot Seat critiques
  • Information
  • Interviews
  • Livestream Chat
  • Mail Bag
  • Member Benefits
  • Promos
  • Site News
  • Studios
  • Surviving Creativity
  • To-Do List
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • Webcomics Confidential
  • Webcomics Weekly
  • Webcomics.com Poll

Tags

AdSense advertising Comic Easel comments composition contract copyright creativity exercise credit cards Crowdfunding digital lettering digital publishing Facebook Google Analytics holiday Humor IP KDP Kickstarter Kindle legal lettering line weight Longform comics Manga Studio merchandise NCS panels Patreon Promotion PulsePoint readers revenue SEO shipping social media Square taxes trademark Twitter typography Web design word balloons WordPress writing

Special Features

Just now, in the forum…

  • Patreon: upfront charging or not?
  • Longform webcomics
  • Quantity time vs quality time on social media
  • Writing a Slice of life
  • Can’t Set Up WordPress Site

Recent Posts

  • March To Do List
  • How to launch a new comic
  • Twitter announced paid-content feature “Super Follows”
  • Webcomics Confidential #48: Spamming Your Patreon Backers
  • Line breaks in word balloons

Recent Replies

  • Jaycee Knight on Patreon: upfront charging or not?
  • Brad Guigar on Longform webcomics
  • Brad Guigar on Patreon: upfront charging or not?
  • Shadowmark Productions on Can’t Set Up WordPress Site
  • Brad Guigar on Can’t Set Up WordPress Site

Recent Topics

  • Patreon: upfront charging or not? by Jaycee Knight
  • Longform webcomics by MynameizJR
  • Quantity time vs quality time on social media by MrMcCloud
  • Writing a Slice of life by MrMcCloud
  • Can’t Set Up WordPress Site by edustin78

Recent Comments

  • Shadowmark Productions on Twitter announced paid-content feature “Super Follows”
  • Shadowmark Productions on How to launch a new comic
  • Jaycee Knight on Twitter announced paid-content feature “Super Follows”
  • Jaycee Knight on Line breaks in word balloons
  • Jaycee Knight on Line breaks in word balloons
  • My Subscription
  • Contact
  • Store
  • Terms of Service
  • Account
  • Membership List

©2007-2021 Webcomics.com | Powered by WordPress with ComicPress | Subscribe: RSS | Back to Top ↑